;doc: balance assertions and multiple files: clarify again, add tests

hledger/hledger.m4.md

@@ -1679,25 +1679,17 @@ The exception is when you reorder multiple postings on the same day, to the same
 ### Assertions and multiple files
 
 If an account has transactions appearing in multiple files, balance assertions can still work - 
-but *only if those files are in a parent-child relationship, using [include directives](#include-directive)*.
+but *only if those files are part of a hierarchy made by [include directives](#include-directive)*.
 
-If the same files are siblings, the assertions will not work.
+If the same files are specified with two `-f` options on the command line,
-For example if you specify them with two `-f` options on the command line,
+the assertions in the second will not see the balances from the first.
-the assertions in one will not see the balances from the other.
 
-But also, if a parent file includes the two subfiles with two side-by-side `include` directives, this too will fail (I think I have that right).
+To work around this, arrange your files in a hierarchy with `include`.
-Assertions in one subfile will not see the balances from the other.
+Or, you could concatenate the files temporarily, and process them like one big file.
-
-To work around this, arrange your files in parent child relationships with `include`.
-Eg make one subfile include the other (it doesn't matter which way round).
-
-Or, you could concatenate the files temporarily, and process them like one big file. Eg:\
-`hledger print -I | hledger -f- CMD`
 
 Why does it work this way ? 
 It might be related to hledger's goal of stable predictable reports.
-File hierarchy is considered "permanent" - it's part of your data.
+File hierarchy is considered "permanent", part of your data, while the order of command line options/arguments is not.
-Whereas the order of sibling files (on the command line at least) is transient - it can change from one command to the next.
 We don't want transient changes to be able to change the meaning of the data.
 Eg it would be frustrating if tomorrow all your balance assertions broke because you wrote command line arguments in a different order.
 (Discussion welcome.)

hledger/test/journal/assertions.test

@@ -493,3 +493,12 @@ $ hledger -f - check -I -s
 $ hledger -f - check assertions -I
 >2 /Balance assertion failed/
 >=1
+
+# ** 32. Assertions don't see balances from previous sibling -f files
+$ hledger check assertions -f assertions1.j -f assertions2.j
+>2 /assertion failed/
+>= 1
+
+# ** 33. Assertions do see balances from parents and previous siblings/children in an include hierarchy
+$ hledger check assertions -f assertions11.j
+

hledger/test/journal/assertions1.j

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+; assertions1.j
+
+2025-01-01
+  (a)    1 = 1

hledger/test/journal/assertions11.j

@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
+; assertions11.j
+
+2025-01-11
+  (a)    11 = 11  ; first assertion
+
+include assertions21.j
+include assertions22.j
+
+2025-03-11
+  (a)    100 = 185  ; sees balance from previous children

hledger/test/journal/assertions2.j

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+; assertions2.j
+
+2025-01-02
+  (a)    1 = 2  ; won't see balance from previous sibling -f file

hledger/test/journal/assertions21.j

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+; assertions21.j
+
+2025-01-21
+  (a)    21 = 32  ; sees balance from parent
+
+include assertions31.j
+

hledger/test/journal/assertions22.j

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+; assertions22.j
+
+2025-02-22 * 
+  (a)    22 = 85  ; sees balance from parent and previous siblings/children included by parent

hledger/test/journal/assertions31.j

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+; assertions31.j
+
+2025-01-31
+  (a)   31 = 63  ; sees balance from parent and grandparent